Architectural Review for Residential Development
There is established an Architectural Review Board for the Village of Grafton for promoting compatible development, aesthetics, stability, or property values, and to prevent impairment or depreciation of existing developments.
No structure can be erected, moved, reconstructed, extended, enlarged, or have its exterior altered or changed without the Architectural Review Board's approval. Small accessory structures are exempt unless the Community Development Director requests a determination by the Architectural Review Board. Architectural plans are also subject to the review and approval of the Plan Commission if the proposed building(s) are also subject to Site Plan Review.
The Architectural Review Board consists of five members. Members are residents of the Village appointed by the Village President and confirmed by the Village Board. Terms are for three-year periods. The Board elects the Chairman.
Any person or persons aggrieved by any decision of the Architectural Review Board may appeal the decision to the Zoning Board of Appeals. Such appeal shall be filed with the Zoning Administrator within thirty (30) days after filing of the decision with the Zoning Administrator.
Principles and Standards Review
In their consideration of applications for architectural review, the Community Development Director, Plan Commission, and Architectural Review Board shall consider and evaluate the propriety of granting the approval in terms of the effect of the application on the general purposes for which architectural approval is required. The Community Development Director, Plan Commission, and Architectural Review Board (as applicable) in the review, approval or denial of the Architectural Review Application use the following principles and standards for architectural review. These are also intended to be a design aid for builders and owners to use in the preparation of architectural plans. A Building Permit shall not be issued for any single-family residence, two-family residential structure, multiple-family residential structure, or nonresidential building which does not meet the requirements of this Section. In addition, no building or remodeling of a building which is located in the area subject to the Grafton Downtown Master Plan as adopted by the Village of Grafton Plan Commission on February 23, 1999, shall be permitted unless said building or proposed remodeling complies with the downtown master plan design guidelines included in that master plan.
Important Building Plan Submittal Checklist
All plans must meet the following requirements:
Residential Development(Single-Family Structures, Two-Family Structures, and Individual Lot Plans for Such Structures). General.
____No two (2) single-family dwellings or two-family dwellings of similar front elevation or facade shall be repeated on any abutting lots or within five (5) lots on either side of the street on which the dwellings front, including lots which are directly across the street from one another. Front elevations or facades are deemed to be similar when there is no substantial difference in roof lines; and no substantial change in windows of either size, location or type; and either no change in the color of materials used (rather than a change in shade), or no substantial change in the kind of materials except where such buildings are part of a unified development and similar building designs are approved by a unanimous vote of the Architectural Review Board.
The following differences in the roof lines of single-family dwellings or two-family dwellings as seen from the front of the dwelling are deemed sufficient to render buildings containing such changes and built on adjacent lots to be dissimilar:
____Changing gable roofs to hip roofs,
____Providing an intersecting gable roof on the main gable roof, if the height of the intersecting roof is at least fifty (50) percent of the height of the main roof. Providing an intersecting hip roof on the main hip roof, if the height of the intersecting hip roof is at least fifty (50) percent of the height of the main roof,
____A shed roof when used as a front porch roof for a minimum of fifty (50) percent of the entire width of the house, excluding area of the garage,
____A substantial difference in roof line is deemed to exist if the front soffit is increased significantly and is combined with columns at least six (6) inches in width or other architectural features of a similar magnitude which reach the roof line of the highest story, or
____Rotating gable roofs ninety (90) degrees on the building.
On a tri-level residence or other building type that has three (3) independent major roof areas, the changing of two (2) out of three (3) rooflines shall be acceptable as a substantial change. Acknowledging certain design elements may prevent the changing of all three (3) rooflines; it is desired that the roofs with the greatest impact in the streetscape be changed.
The following changes are not deemed sufficient to make adjacent structures dissimilar:
-A gable roof atop a hip roof,
-A hip roof atop a gable roof,
-Small gable or hip projections above windows,
-Change in soffit overhang or minor variation in eave height, or
-Skylight and cupola.
The following differences in the size, location or type of windows are deemed sufficient to render buildings containing such changes and built on adjacent lots to be dissimilar:
____Changing from single windows to a multiple window arrangement (ganged units),
____Changing from multiple window arrangement to single windows,
____Changing the type of windows (e.g., a casement to double hung), or
____Providing a bay or bow window in the area of the predominant window,
The following change shall not be deemed sufficient to constitute a substantial change in windows:
-The addition or subtraction of muntin bars (dividing lights).
-Where, because of its size, location or design, one window is the predominant window on the front elevation or face, if the size, location or type of that window is changed to render the dwelling dissimilar, then no other window need be changed.
Construction Material or Color.
The following differences in construction material between adjacent single-family dwellings or two-family dwellings as seen from the front of the dwellings shall be deemed sufficient to render buildings containing such changes and built on adjacent lots to be dissimilar.
____Four (4) inch exposure horizontal siding,
____Eight (8) inch exposure horizontal siding,
____Stone facing, or
____Stucco/stucco to board and trim.
____When materials are changed, the change must occur throughout the front facade or elevation for a minimum of one (1) story in height.
____Color change shall be made by significant changes in adjacent colors. The change must be one of color rather than merely of the shade.
Seven sets of building plans and surveys are required. One survey and one of the sets shall be in an 11" x 17" format signed by the subdivision control committee, if required.
Architectural Review Board